I was backing Wales all the way this morning, and would have been really chuffed to see the Wallabies heading home with nothing to show for all their brash talk coming into the tournament.
But it was the Australians who coped better with their semi-final defeat and they were able to raise their performance and collect the bronze medal. The Aussies were inspired by an all-round performance from World Cup bench warmer Berrick Barnes.
The game highlighted one thing very clearly to me. Robbie Deans’ persistence with a clearly out of form Quade Cooper was a big part of the Aussies relative failure in the tournament. On paper, losing to the All Blacks in the semis is nothing to be embarrassed about. But it was the nature of the Wallabies’ performances against Ireland, the Springboks and then New Zealand that will disappoint their fans.
They rightly lost to Ireland (although some of those calls at the scrum were a bit rough) and should have lost to the Springboks, who butchered their opportunities.
In rugby, you can’t put defeat down to one player, but watching the impact that Berrick Barnes had on the Aussies today enforces the case of those who were calling for him to replace Cooper earlier in the Rugby World Cup. Cooper never got anywhere near his SupeRugby or Tri-Nations form and was naively sucked into the circus that developed around him. The fact that Deans and the Australians were willing to adjust their defensive strategy and in-play structure in order to accommodate Cooper’s unwillingness or inability to defend says more about the planning than the player.
The Wallabies will be left asking “What if Barnes has started?” I’d say that they would have been a lot more convincing in their victory over the Springboks and would have at least had a chance against the hosts.
It will be interesting to see the way that Deans approaches the next few months with the Wallabies. With an eye on the Lions tour in 2013, the Australians need to decide who their go-to man is going to be.
Mehrtens, Larkham, Carter, Honiball, O’Gara, Wilkinson… These names roll off the tongue when supporters talk of excellent flyhalves. They based their game around doing the basics well to start with and then taking it from there. That approach is not in Cooper’s makeup and his role within the Wallaby set up needs to very carefully considered. Cooper is easily young enough to be there in four years time, but is he willing to be a responsible part of a team? His attitude says no.
They need to get Barnes more involved in the side before he takes another knock to the noggin and is forced to retire. If that’s at the expense of Cooper that would be just fine.